Peloton Yearbook, Class of 2025

Back by popular demand (because I wanted to write it again), The Clip Out is once again rolling out the virtual red carpet for Peloton Instructor Superlatives. Welcome to Peloton High, Class of 2025, where the instructors are dope, the vibes are groovy, and the rizz? Still off the charts. For real. We did it last year, and we couldn’t resist doing it again. So let’s see who’s earning a coveted Instructor Superlative this year!

Best Kept Secret (tie)

Nico Sarani

Ash Pryor

Yogis and Row-owners already know the deal, but we’re here to let the cat fully out of the bag—these two are Peloton’s hidden gems.

Yes, Nico is technically a German instructor, but don’t let that fool you—she’s based at PSNY. We’re convinced some members assume all her classes are in German. Newsflash: they’re not, she teaches plenty of classes in English. Nico is the feel-good Yoga instructor you didn’t know you were missing.

And then there’s Ash Pryor. For the love of all that’s holy—Peloton, please expand her reach beyond the Row. Yes, she’s a powerhouse on the platform, but that’s not all she is. She recently ran her first half marathon (at a sexy pace, no less), regularly crushes workouts on the Bike, and posts strength videos (lifting literal instructors!) that prove she’s strong AF. People who follow her know: Ash isn’t just a Row instructor—she’s a full-on fitness force. Seriously, what are you waiting for, Peloton?

Best Thirst Trap

Erik Jager

Last year brought us a fierce two-way tie for this category, but this time, one instructor has clearly taken the crown. Erik Jäger has been thirst trap training like it’s his sport of choice—and he’s winning. He doesn’t just dabble in the art of the smolder; he commits to it. Shirtless selfies? Check. Workout mirror shots? Double check. Bedroom eyes through a protein shake haze? Probably! And the best part? Erik knows exactly what he’s doing—and he’s not sorry about it. Honestly, we hope he never stops.  

Exhibit A

Exhibit B

Exhibit C

Exhibit D

We could go on (and on, and on, and on…seriously).

Most Likely to be Invited to a Party

Tunde Oyeneyin

If you’ve scrolled through Tunde’s Instagram lately, you already know—she’s basically got a standing RSVP. Rebecca and Andy’s dreamy Italian wedding? She was there. Tropical getaway with Katie and Rad? Yep, she was there, too. Recently, she even pulled triple duty at her best friend’s wedding, serving as officiant, makeup artist, and guest (because why do less?). And when she’s not traveling the globe, she’s turning the gym into a social event—working out with Olivia, Katie, Ash, and anyone else lucky enough to get the invite. This past year, Tunde wasn’t just at the party—she was the party. So yeah, this one was obvious. Tunde was everywhere this year and we’re convinced she’s the glue that holds everyone together. 

Cutest Couple

Alex Karwoski and his Shorts

Find yourself someone as loyal to you as Alex Karwoski is to his shorty-shorts. Seriously—this is a love story for the ages. While other instructors rotate their wardrobes like fashion influencers, Alex stays devoted to one tried-and-true dress code: thighs out, always. No matter the season, no matter the workout, those shorts are showing up and showing off. And honestly? We support it. It’s a bold, breezy, beautifully consistent relationship. At this point, we’re not even sure where Alex ends and the shorts begin. True love does exist, and it’s got a 3-inch inseam.

Best Laugh 

Bradley Rose

With an infectious cackle and Flynn Rider smolder, Bradley Rose proves that working out can be hilarious. No in-studio members to banter with? No problem. Bradley needs only his own stream-of-consciousness commentary to crack himself up—and us right along with him. One minute he’s mid-interval, the next he’s laughing at whatever just popped into his head (and immediately out of his mouth). Take one of his classes and try not to grin. We dare you. You’ll be sweaty… and absolutely smiling.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Bradley Rose (@bradley_rose23)

Most Likely to Brighten Your Day

Katie Wang

Katie Wang is basically a walking beam of California sunshine—radiating warmth, joy, and just enough sass to keep you smiling through the sweat. Whether she’s telling a hilariously self-deprecating story, sharing the latest antics of her cat, Ma’am, or sharing visits with her Grandma, Katie has a magical way of turning your mood around. Sure, she’s going to make you work—your muscles will definitely feel it—but somehow, your heart feels lighter, too. With Katie, it’s not just about the reps; it’s about the vibes. And those? Immaculate.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Katie Wang (@katiewongspelledwang)

Favorite Fashionista (tie)

Matty Maggiacomo

Aditi Shah

Honestly, we almost gave Matty Maggiacomo “Biggest Thirst Trap” this year—because let’s be real, the man knows what he’s doing. But beyond the low-key thirst trap photos, Matty is a full-on fashion force. A quick scroll through his Instagram reveals red carpet-ready looks, Broadway premieres, and Halloween costumes so committed, they deserve their own awards. Matty doesn’t just wear clothes—he serves looks.

And then there’s Aditi Shah, who may or may not be secretly moonlighting as a Bond girl. We can’t know for sure, but there are signs—namely, her impossibly chic and always on-point wardrobe. From serene yoga flows to jet-setting across the globe, Aditi turns every sidewalk into a runway. Her closet? It’s probably the stuff of fashionista fantasies. We don’t know what’s more flexible—her yoga practice or her style range.

Funniest Without Trying

Hannah Frankson

It all started with an early-pandemic Reel: Hannah Frankson, a loaf of bread, a can of beans—and the driest, most unexpectedly hilarious “cook-with-me” segment the internet had ever seen. Beans on toast have never been so funny. From that moment on, we were hooked. Whether she’s casually filming in front of her unmistakably phallic-shaped mirror or providing running commentary on… well, anything, Hannah is effortlessly hysterical. Her IG Reels? Basically a one-woman comedy tour. If she ever takes the show on the road, we’re buying front-row seats.

Best Besties 

Erik Jäger and Jon Hosking

Is there anything more pure than the gym-bro bond of two besties? Absolutely not. Whether they’re wobbling through a BOSU ball balance challenge, experimenting with “animal flow” (still unclear if that’s a legit workout or just a cleverly disguised excuse to hang out), trying Pilates, or—our personal favorite—tackling “Couples Yoga,” Erik and Jon’s content is a highlight reel of friendship goals. Last year, we declared that Hosky had bromantic chemistry with everyone, but this year, it’s his dynamic with Erik that’s stealing the show. Easy, breezy, and endlessly entertaining—these two are a bestie dream-team.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by ERIK JÄGER (@hauptstadttrainer)

Most Likely to Send Encouraging Texts at 2am

Dr. Chelsea Jackson Roberts

Is she actually texting at 2am? Probably not—and honestly, we hope she’s fast asleep. But would she send you an encouraging pick-me-up at 2am if you needed it? We’d bet on it. Chelsea radiates authenticity and heart, and we’re pretty sure she’d wrap you in a virtual hug the moment you needed one. With her signature blend of wisdom, warmth, and momma-bear energy, she just feels like the kind of person who checks in on her people—whether it’s a midday pep talk or a middle-of-the-night “you’ve got this.” That said… please let her sleep.

Biggest Prankster

Olivia Amato

Olivia Amato is the kind of class clown who flies under the radar—until it’s too late. With that angelic face and demure vibe, you’ll never see the prank coming… and that’s exactly how she likes it. She’s a total trickster via text and absolutely cannot be trusted around an unlocked email account (in the most delightful way, of course). And let’s be clear—no one is off-limits. Whether it’s her fellow instructors or her husband, if Olivia spots an opportunity, she’s taking it. Then she’ll post a Reel so the rest of us can enjoy the mischief. Think you’re safe? Think again. Olivia probably already has your number. Literally. 

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Olivia Amato Waldron (@oliviaamato)

Most Likely to Burn the Ultimate Mix CD/Best Playlists

Jenn Sherman

Let’s be honest—who else would win this? Sure, all Peloton instructors know how to build a solid playlist, but only one is so legendary at it, she has multiple signature series built entirely around her musical genius. That’s right–multiple series, plural. Jenn Sherman doesn’t just make playlists, she curates full-blown soundtracks for your sweat sessions. Whether you’re riding to her “My Mixtape” classes or belting your heart out during her “Epic Singalong” rides, one thing’s guaranteed: your ears are in for a treat. Her command of epic jams would make any DJ do a double take. Jenn is a master at spinning the pedals and the tunes.

Most Likely to be Found in a Bookstore

Selena Samuela

Need a new page-turner? Ask Selena. A self-proclaimed bookworm and proud founder of A Court of Books and Baddies (yes, named after A Court of Thorns and Roses) book club, Selena has fully leaned into her literary era. She’s reviewing novels, hosting live chats on her second Instagram (@acourtofbooksandbaddies), and even bringing her love of books into the studio with “bookish” Peloton classes. This isn’t a passing hobby—it’s a whole vibe. Selena’s passion for storytelling adds a brand-new chapter to her already dynamic presence, and we’re absolutely loving it.

Best Content Creator

Cliff Dwenger

Peloton instructors create content almost as often as they create new fitness classes–and a lot of them excel at it. But, there’s one instructor that rises above the rest in the content creation department, and that’s Cliff Dwenger.  Enlisting the help of his wife and daughter, Cliff creates content that’s both funny and relatable, giving us glimpses into his life outside of the Peloton studio as a dad and a husband who’s devoted to keeping it real…and entertaining.  With a new baby on the way, we can’t wait to see what the Dwenger family has in store for us next. 

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Coach Cliff (@afrow_cliff)

Most Likely to Revive Blockbuster

Sam Yo

If there’s one Peloton instructor most likely to bring back Friday night trips to Blockbuster, it’s Sam Yo. No one serves up cinematic devotion quite like him—his rides are packed with movie magic, from official themed classes to stealth tributes (looking at you, Top Gun ride 👀). Sam doesn’t just play the hits; he curates full-on film experiences, complete with the kind of nostalgia that makes you want to rewind your VHS and grab some microwave popcorn. The last Blockbuster may have closed in 2019, but if Sam could have his way, we’d all be scanning plastic cases under fluorescent lights again. And honestly? We’d sign up for that membership.

Person You’d Want to be Stuck on a Deserted Island With (tie)

Becs Gentry

Alex K. 

Marcel D.

Let’s face it: if you’re going to be stranded, you want people who can keep calm, stay strong and, have some niche skills. Becs ran seven marathons on seven continents in seven days last year. That’s the kind of mental (and physical) toughness you want when the going gets rough. Plus, if anything is chasing you… she’ll outrun it. Probably twice.

Alex is an Olympic rower. Translation: we’re getting off that island, no question. All he needs is a DIY raft and maybe a volleyball named Wilson for company, and boom—he’s got us back on the mainland by sunset.

And last but absolutely not least: Marcel Dinkins. She’s a Peloton instructor and a combat veteran. Whether your deserted island vibes are “sunny paradise” or “mildly terrifying survival scenario,” Marcel’s the one you want leading the charge. She’s strong, strategic, and definitely not getting outsmarted by anything on that island.

Let’s just say—if this trio showed up on Survivor, the rest of the cast should just pack it up now.

Best Instructor Celeb Lookalike 

Andy Speer and Matthew Davis

Warner Huntington III, is that you?? Or is it Andy Speer fresh off the treadmill and straight into Harvard Law? The resemblance between Andy and Matthew Davis is uncanny—it’s giving “You got into Harvard Law?” / “What, like it’s hard?” energy in the best way.

We’re not saying Andy is Warner, but if he suddenly shows up with a popped collar and a tragic misunderstanding of Elle Woods’ brilliance, we wouldn’t be surprised.

P.S. Andy and Rebecca—if you’re reading this, the Peloton world needs a Warner and Elle couples costume. Preferably with Bruiser in tow. Don’t disappoint us. We object!

Best Hair

Rebecca Kennedy

Rebecca Kennedy has been on a full-blown hair journey this year, and the results? Absolutely next level. Her long, bouncy, envy-inducing locks are the stuff of shampoo commercial dreams. But the best part? She’s not a gatekeeper. RK regularly shares her hair care secrets in detailed Reels, and we are so here for it. If the Breck Girls were still a thing, Rebecca would be the face of the whole campaign. 

Best Boyfriend

Jon Hosking

We have absolutely no clue what Hosky’s relationship status is—but after his Valentine’s Day visit to PSNY, it honestly doesn’t matter. He became everyone’s boyfriend that day, and we’re not mad about it.

Whether he’s handing out roses to Members IRL or showing up in full Cupid gear to surprise Matty Maggiacomo in the Tread studio, Jon radiates romantic comedy energy in the best way. Honestly, anyone that smooth with a rose might have a future on The Bachelor—and we’d all accept that final rose.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Peloton Studios (@pelotonstudios)

Whoever holds the key to that British heart? Consider us all a little jealous.

Class Dismissed

And there you have it—this year’s Peloton Senior Superlatives, packed with fashion icons, pranksters, besties, and beans-on-toast comedians. Whether they’re lifting your spirits (or just making you lift), our favorite instructors continue to bring the laughs, the looks, and the love—all while making us sweat. So here’s to the shoutouts, the shorty-shorts, and the spontaneous 2am pep talks. We’ll be back next year with more unofficial awards, but until then, see you on the leaderboard!

---

Tune in to The Clip Out every Friday to hear Tom and Crystal’s take on this and other hot Pelotopics. We’re available on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Google Podcasts, iHeart, TuneIn. Be sure and follow us so you never miss an episode. You can also find the show online on Facebook.com/TheClipOut. While you’re there, like the page and join the group. Lastly, find us on our YouTube channel, YouTube.com/TheClipOut, where you can watch all of our shows.

See something in the Peloton Universe that you think we should know? Visit theclipout.com and click on Submit a Tip!